Sustainable Energy Watch (SEW)

ABOUT SEW | BIBLIOGRAPHY | ANNEXES
 
Energy Technology Appraisal Criteria
 

ENERGY TECHNOLOGY APPRAISAL CRITERIA
     
ENVIRONMENTAL CRITERIA NON-ENVIRONMENTAL CRITERIA  NON-ENVIRONMENTAL CRITERIA  NON-ENVIRONMENTAL CRITERIA 
(alphabetical order) FINANCIAL VIABILITY  SUPPLY SECURITY WIDER ECONOMICS
acoustic noise 
aerial visibility effects 
agricultural intensification 
air quality 
altered flow rates and patterns 
ambient temperature change 
aqueous radioactive pollution 
behavioural interference 
carbon monoxide emissions 
catastrophic dam burst 
catastrophic pollution potential 
cultural or community disruption 
drainage disruption 
ecological or habitat disturbance 
electromagnetic interference 
elevated water levels 
endangered species impacts 
enhanced coastal erosion 
enshading or reflection 
entrainment of aquatic biota 
eutrophication 
explosive or incendiary effects 
fisheries interference 
food chain residues 
gaseous waste volume management 
greenhouse gas emissions 
hazard to bird flight 
heavy metal releases 
hydrogen sulphide emissions 
induced seismicity 
induced subsidence 
interference with migration 
land use change 
latent human health effects 
liquid waste volume management 
local ambient CO2/O2 balance 
marine debris 
marine hydrocarbon releases 
marine life morbidity 
mechanical hazards 
micro-climate effects 
mutagenicity or teratogenicity 
navigational hazards 
nitrogen oxide emissions 
occupational health 
occupational safety 
particulate emissions 
prompt public health impacts 
psychological trauma 
radioactive emissions 
resource depletion 
road traffic 
rural population impacts 
salinity change 
sedimentation changes 
soil acidification 
soil erosion 
soil sterilisation 
soil structure loss 
soil toxification or contamination 
solid waste volume management 
stratospheric ozone depletion 
sulphur oxide emissions 
thermal radiation effects 
toxic aerial emissions 
tritiated water emissions 
tropospheric ozone enhancement 
turbidity changes 
visual aesthetic offence 
volatile organic emissions 
water abstraction demand 
water quality effects 
Commercial Availability 
technical feasibility 
state of development 
implementation rates 
production capacity 
accessibility of finance

Cost Effectiveness 
economic cost 
capital intensity 
avoidable costs 

Cost Stability 
fuel markets 
waste management 
decommissioning 
cost of capital 
regulatory restrictions 

System Integration 
power quality 
grid connection 
conventional substitution 
unit size 
lead times 
dispatchability 
ramp rates 
cycling rates 

Resource Sufficiency 
resource significance 
total contribution

Conversion Efficiency 
 

Resource Sustainability 
national depletion control 
sustainable development
 

Domestic Self Reliance
indigenous resources 
equipment supply 
infrastructure
 

Vulnerability to Disruption 
military action 
political action 
commercial action 
industrial action 
technical reliability 
contingency measures 
flexibility
 

Portfolio Diversity 
resource options 
technological options 
geographical locations 
commercial vendors 
commercial carriers 
resource variability 
utility operators 
resource availability 
exporting countries 
resource accessibility 
domestic unions

Balance of Payments 
fuel imports 
equipment supply 
export promotion
 

Economic Development 
regional development 
rural development 
resource use
 

Employment 
employment intensity 
mode of employment
 

Industrial Policy 
stimulation of innovation 
technological merit 
sectoral balance 
material requirements 
strategic flexibility
 

Fiscal Issues 
public expenditure 
state guarantees 
capital requirements 
tax revenues
 

Market Compatibility 
internal energy market 
privatisability 
regulatory requirements 
commercial concentration 
price transparency 
cost internalisation
 

Military Security 
capability implications 
vulnerability to attack 
proliferation potential 
Foreign Relations 
special relationships 
transboundary liabilities 
internat. collaboration 
international development 
global political stability
 

Social Welfare 
wealth distribution 
fuel poverty
 

Political Attributes 
short term expediency 
public acceptability 
siting 
public participation 
ownership and control 
accountability 
centralisation
cultural implications
ideological implications
institutional continuity

 
List taken from: "Government Performance Criteria for the Strategic Appraisal of Energy Supply Technologies" by Andrew Stirling, Dec. 1994.